HAHAHAHAHA I AM HONORED TO BE IN CHARGE OF YOUR YJ-MAKING DECISIONS. I am currently struggling super-hard in my soul because it's down to my ladies M'gann and Artemis (I do love Zatanna, too, but she hasn't had as much screentime/development yet so I am willing to let her go). I am currently leaning towards M'gann just because she is much more reviled in fandom and the FUCK YOU SHE'S AWESOME factor is strong, but uggggggggh Artemis my prickly sensible sarcastic guilty redemption-seeking beloved. ;__________; BUT ALSO M'GANN IS SO PRECIOUS AND FASCINATING AND KIND AND EARNEST AND SHE LIKES TO BAKE? I'm, uh. Having a hard time, is what I mean to say here. (Probably I am going to go with M'gann though because seriously, man, fandom is such a jerk to her that I WANT TO GET WHAT INEFFECTUAL REVENGE I CAN. ):<)

Also I did read the first four PLL books but have no experience with the show, lolllll. I went with the Santana strategy and gave my vote to Emily Fields, the awesome queer lady of color, so that is who I would recommend if you don't care!