It's weird, since David Boreanaz is definitely more of my usual type (I am not petite, so short, skinny guys make me feel enormous), but I always found Spike attractive and Angel not so much. I think it's the personality, honestly. JM just oozes charisma and sex appeal, and that makes any guy attractive to me, lol. :) He would probably make me feel enormous in person, though, because standing next to SMG definitely helps him on TV.

I do think DB is HOTTTT on Bones. Maybe he just had to grow into it?