I don't think she's horrible at doing non-badass, but I agree that she should stick to badass.

Also agreed about Dichen and Olivia - I felt Dichen's different personalities came naturally, as did Olivia Williams's personality change.

I think the thing with Eliza is that she'd probably be good in non-badass roles if she got them more often. She cameo'd in Ugly Betty, and even there she was a crazy chick.

I kinda wish she'd done a Faith spinoff, because that would've been fun. I know they were talking about it, but she didn't like the idea.